Discover more from System Design Newsletter
11 Reasons Why YouTube Was Able to Support 100 Million Video Views a Day With Only 9 Engineers
#5: Read Now - YouTube Top 11 Scalability Techniques (7 minutes)
Get the powerful template to approach system design for FREE on newsletter sign-up:
February 2005 - California, United States.
3 early employees from PayPal wanted to build a platform to share videos. So, they co-founded YouTube in their garage.
But they had limited financial resources. So, they funded YouTube through credit card debt and infrastructure borrowing. The financial limitations forced them to create innovative scalability techniques.
In the next year, they hit 100 million video views a day. And they did this with only 9 engineers.
Consider sharing this post with someone who wants to study scalability patterns.
Here are the 11 YouTube scalability techniques:
1. Magic Flywheel
They took a scientific approach to scalability: collect and analyze system data.
Their workflow was a constant loop: identify and fix bottlenecks. This approach avoided the need for high-end hardware - and reduced hardware costs.
2. Boring Tech Stack
They kept their tech stack simple and used proven technologies. Their tech stack:
MySQL stored metadata: video titles, tags, descriptions, and user data. Because it was easy to fix issues in MySQL.
Lighttpd web server served video.
Suse Linux as the operating system. They used Linux tools to inspect the system behavior: strace, ssh, rsync, vmstat, and tcpdump.
Python on the application server. Because it offered many reusable libraries and they didn’t want to reinvent the wheel. In other words, Python allowed rapid and flexible development. Python was never a bottleneck based on their measurements.
Yet they used Python-to-C compiler and C-language extensions to run CPU-intensive tasks.
3. Keep It Simple
They considered software architecture to be the root of scalability. They didn’t follow buzzwords to scale. But kept the architecture simple - making code reviews easier. And it allowed them to rearchitect fast to meet changing needs. For example, they pivoted from a dating site to a video-sharing site.
They kept the network path simple. Because network appliances have scalability limitations.
Also they used commodity hardware. It allowed them to reduce power consumption and maintenance fees - and keep the costs low.
Besides they kept the scale-aware code opaque to application development.
4. Choose Your Battles
They outsourced their problems. Because they wanted to focus on important things. They didn’t have the time or resources to build their own infrastructure to serve popular videos. So, they put the popular videos on a third-party CDN. The benefits:
Low latency. Because of fewer network hops from the user
High performance. Because it served videos from memory
High availability. Because of automatic replication
They served less popular videos from a colocated data center. And used the software RAID to improve the performance through multi-disk access parallelism. Also tweaked their servers to prevent cache thrashing.
They kept their infrastructure in a colocated data center for 2 reasons. To tweak servers with ease to meet their needs. And to negotiate their own contracts.
Each video had 4 thumbnails. So, they faced problems in serving small objects: lots of disk seeks, and filesystem limits. So, they put thumbnails in BigTable. It is a distributed data store with many benefits:
Avoids small file problems by clustering files
Low latency with a multi-level cache
Easy to provision
Also they faked data to prevent expensive transactions. For example, they faked the video view count and asynchronously updated the counter. A popular technique today to approximate correctness is the bloom filter. It is a probabilistic data structure.
5. Pillars of Scalability
They relied on 3 pillars of scalability: stateless, replication, and partitioning.
They kept their web servers stateless. And scaled it out via replication.
They replicated the database server for read scalability and high availability. And load balanced the traffic among replicas. But this approach caused problems: replication lag and issues with write scalability.
So, they partitioned the database for improved write scalability, cache locality, and performance. Also it reduced their hardware costs by 30%.
Besides they studied data access patterns to determine the partition level. For example, they studied popular queries, joins, and transactional consistency. And chose the user as the partition level.
6. Solid Engineering Team
A knowledgeable team is an important asset to scalability.
They kept the team size small for improved communication - 9 engineers. And their team was great at cross-disciplinary skills.
7. Don’t Repeat Yourself
They used cache to prevent repeating expensive operations. It allowed them to scale reads.
Also they implemented caching at many levels - and it reduced latency.
8. Rank Your Stuff
They ranked video-watch traffic over everything else. So, they kept a dedicated cluster of resources for video-watch traffic. It provided high availability.
9. Prevent the Thundering Herd
The thundering herd problem occurs if many concurrent clients query a server. It degrades performance.
They used jitter to prevent the thundering herd problem. For example, they added jitter to the cache expiry of popular videos.
10. Play the Long Game
They focused on macro-level of things: algorithms, and scalability. They did quick hacks to buy more time to build long-term solutions. For example, stubbing bad API with Python to prevent short-term problems.
They tolerated imperfection in their components. When hit a bottleneck: they either rewrote the component or got rid of it.
They traded off efficiency for scalability. Examples:
They chose Python over C
They kept clear boundaries between components to scale out. And tolerated latency
They optimized the software to be fast enough. But didn’t obsess with machine efficiency
They served video from a server location based on bandwidth availability. And not based on latency
11. Adaptive Evolution
They tweaked the system to meet their needs. Examples:
Critical components used RPC instead of HTTP REST. It improved performance
Custom BSON as the data serialization format. It offered high-performance
Eventual consistency in certain parts of the application for scalability. For example, the read-your-writes consistency model for user comments
Studied Python to prevent common pitfalls. Also relied on profiling
Customized open-source software
Optimized database queries
Made non-critical real-time tasks asynchronous
They didn’t waste time writing code to restrict people. Instead adopted great engineering practices - coding conventions to improve their code structure.
Google acquired YouTube in 2006. And it remains the market leader in video sharing with 5 billion video views a day.
According to Forbes, the founders of YouTube have a net worth of 100+ million USD.
Consider subscribing to get simplified case studies delivered straight to your inbox:
Catch up on the popular posts! 🚀
My latest favorite post is the Realtime Chat Client and Server Challenge by. His newsletter aims at upskilling software engineers through real-world coding challenges. So, consider subscribing to his weekly newsletter Coding Challenges. Disclaimer: I put a referral link. Because I'd love to appear on his leaderboard.
A huge thank you to everybody who supports this newsletter.
We are now 4,703 subscribers strong, very close to 5K. I think we can get to 5,000 subscribers by 30 September. Y’all are the best.
Word-of-mouth referrals like yours help this community grow - Thank you.
Seattle Conference on Scalability: YouTube Scalability. (2012). YouTube. Available at: YouTube [Accessed 14 Sep. 2023].
www.youtube.com. (n.d.). Scalability at YouTube. [online] Available at YouTube [Accessed 14 Sep. 2023].
didip (2008). Super Sizing Youtube with Python. [online] Available at: https://www.slideshare.net/didip/super-sizing-youtube-with-python.
Wikipedia Contributors (2019). YouTube. [online] Wikipedia. Available at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/YouTube.
highscalability.com. (n.d.). YouTube Architecture - High Scalability -. [online] Available at: http://highscalability.com/youtube-architecture.